Was there a third gunshot victim?

Two people in Jonestown died of gunshot wounds – Jim Jones and Jones’ personal nurse, Annie Moore – yet early in the first week following the deaths, a rumor started circulating that a third person had also been shot. The rumor made its way into the Guyana Inquest a month later, when Cecil Roberts, the Deputy Commissioner for Crime in the Guyana police, testified: “I observed what appeared to be a gunshot wound on an unidentified body of a Caucasian male of about 6 feet tall in a room described to me [by] Odell Rhodes as a psychiatric ward.” In response to a question from a member of the inquest jury a moment later, Roberts added, “I saw no gun in the said room where this body was found with gunshot wound.”

Based upon this testimony, the jury determined, “Jim Jones died from gunshot wounds. Ann Elizabeth Moore gunshot wounds. Unidentified person gunshot also.”

FBI Serial 1407 and State Department cable 4435, which reported the findings of the jury, made the language more conclusive, by stating without equivocation, “an unidentified Caucasian male, about six feet tall, died of gunshot wounds.”

The rumor of the third gunshot victim was false.

In another statement made during the same inquest, Cecil Roberts contradicted himself when he said, “The said dead bodies in particular the body of James Warren Jones and Elisabeth Moore were identified by the said Odell Rhodes and shown to the said Government Pathologist. These two bodies were shown to the said Pathologist as they appeared to have gun shot wounds.”

Odell Rhodes was one of three survivors to accompany Roberts to Jonestown during the first few days after November 18 in an effort to identify bodies before decomposition made them unrecognizable, and he did lead Roberts into the medical unit.  His own statement to the Guyana inquest, however, makes no mention of a third gunshot victim.  Moreover, the 1981 book Awake in a Nightmare by Ethan Feinsod, which is based in large part on interviews with Odell Rhodes, states that “Two [people] had died from gunshot wounds.”

If that’s the case, who was the third person mistakenly described as a gunshot victim, and how was the error made?

The preponderance of the evidence is that the person was Don Sly – known in Jonestown as Ujara – the Temple member who lunged at Rep. Leo Ryan with a knife shortly before the congressman left Jonestown for Port Kaituma on November 18. There is a well-known photograph taken by Greg Robinson of Ryan with a bloody shirt, but the caption accurately notes that it’s the “attempted assassin’s blood.” In other words, rather than injure the congressman, Sly had inadvertently cut himself. After he was subdued, he was taken to the medical clinic for treatment. The medical attention never occurred, and he was left on an examination table. That was where he died of cyanide poisoning, still wearing the clothing stained with his own blood.

The key word in all the descriptions of gunshot victims – both of Annie Moore and Jim Jones, as well as the rumored third victim – is “appeared,” a word omitted in the FBI and State Department’s report. But further investigations set the record straight. Autopsies conducted in the U.S. in mid-December 1978 revealed that Moore and Jones had in fact died of gunshot wounds. A follow-up report written on April 29, 1979 by Col. William Cowan of the Armed Forces Institute of Pathology found “In general summation, two deaths were due to gunshot wounds… With no other demonstrable cause … it must be presumed that cyanide poisoning is the mode of death in the other individuals whether through coercion or self ingestion.”

In short, the person in the medical unit was almost certainly Don Sly. The blood on his shirt made it appear he had a gunshot wound. He did not.

[Note: The editors of this website thank Charlie Puterbaugh for her assistance in researching and documenting this question.]